Beauty Subscription Value Calculator
Your Usage Settings
Key Comparisons
IPSY Glam Bag: $12/month ($15-18 international) with 5 mini products
IPSY Glam Bag Plus: $25/month with 1 full-size + samples
BoxyCharm: $25/month ($35-40 international) with 5-7 full-size products
Note: Full-size products last 3-4x longer than samples. A 1 oz foundation sample lasts 2 weeks but full-size lasts 3 months.
Your Value Analysis
IPSY Analysis
Monthly Cost: $12 + ($15-18 international) =
Product Value: $60-$80 retail value
$2.00-$2.67 per product
BoxyCharm Analysis
Monthly Cost: $25 + ($15-18 international) =
Product Value: $100-$150 retail value
$3.57-$5.00 per product
Value Comparison
When you’re choosing between IPSY and BoxyCharm, the biggest question isn’t just which one has better products-it’s which one actually fits your budget. Both are popular beauty subscription boxes, but they don’t work the same way when it comes to pricing. If you’re trying to figure out if one is more expensive than the other, the answer isn’t as simple as comparing monthly fees. You need to look at what you actually get, how often you get it, and whether you’re paying for value-or just packaging.
IPSY’s Basic Plan: $12 a Month, But Is It Worth It?
IPSY’s most common plan is the Glam Bag for $12 a month. That’s what most people sign up for, and it’s where the confusion starts. At first glance, $12 seems cheap. But here’s the catch: you’re not buying five full-size products. You’re getting about five mini-sized samples, usually travel-sized or tester versions. Most of them are under 1 oz, sometimes even 0.5 oz. That’s not enough to last more than a few uses. If you’re using foundation or concealer daily, you’ll go through a 0.3 oz sample in two weeks. So while the price is low, the actual cost per use can be higher than you think.
IPSY does offer higher-tier plans. The Glam Bag Plus is $25 a month and includes one full-size product, usually a cult favorite like a serum or lipstick. But even then, you’re still getting mostly samples. The real value comes from the ability to customize your profile. IPSY lets you pick your skin tone, hair type, and beauty preferences. That means you get products that actually match your needs-not random stuff you’ll never use.
BoxyCharm: $25 a Month, But You Get Full-Size Stuff
BoxyCharm charges $25 a month, which is more than double IPSY’s base price. But here’s the trade-off: every single item in your box is full-size. No testers. No samples. You get five to seven full-size beauty products every month. That includes foundation, mascara, lipsticks, skincare serums, and sometimes even tools like brushes or sponges. A single full-size foundation from a brand like Rare Beauty or Fenty Beauty can cost $30-$40 in stores. If you get one in your BoxyCharm box, you’re already saving money.
BoxyCharm doesn’t let you customize your box. You get what they send. That’s a gamble. Some months, you’ll love everything. Other months, you’ll end up with two lipsticks you’ll never wear and a body scrub you don’t need. But if you’re okay with surprise beauty, the value per dollar is hard to beat. A typical BoxyCharm box has a retail value of $100-$150. That’s a 75%+ discount on retail. IPSY’s Glam Bag Plus might be worth $60-$80, but you’re paying $25 for it. BoxyCharm gives you more product for less cost per item.
What You Actually Pay Per Product
Let’s break it down. If you stick with IPSY’s $12 Glam Bag, you’re paying $2.40 per product if you get five items. Sounds great-until you realize most of those products are 10% of their full size. If you want a full-size foundation from IPSY, you have to upgrade to the $25 plan. That’s $5 per product if you get five items. But you’re still getting mostly samples.
BoxyCharm gives you five to seven full-size products for $25. That’s $3.57-$5 per full-size item. That’s the same price as IPSY’s higher tier-but you’re getting real, usable quantities. If you use foundation daily, a 1 oz sample lasts two weeks. A full-size 1 oz foundation lasts three months. That’s a huge difference in long-term value.
Hidden Costs: Shipping, Returns, and Unused Products
Both services ship for free in the U.S. But if you live outside the U.S., like in Australia, shipping adds $10-$15 per box. That changes the math. For someone in Sydney, IPSY’s $12 plan becomes $22-$27. BoxyCharm jumps from $25 to $35-$40. Suddenly, the price gap shrinks.
Another hidden cost? Unused products. IPSY’s samples often go unused because they’re too small to commit to. You might try a new lipstick once and never touch it again. With BoxyCharm, you get full-size items you can actually test properly. If you hate something, you can sell it, give it away, or use it for guests. You’re not wasting money-you’re just not using it yourself.
Who Gets More Value? It Depends on Your Beauty Habits
If you’re someone who loves to try new products and doesn’t mind small sizes, IPSY’s $12 plan makes sense. You’ll get variety. You’ll discover new brands. You’ll have enough to test a few things before buying full-size. But if you’re someone who actually uses makeup every day-foundation, concealer, mascara, lipstick-then BoxyCharm gives you more usable products per dollar.
Think about it this way: If you spend $12 a month on IPSY and end up buying one full-size product every three months because you liked the sample, you’re spending $12 + $30 = $42 every three months. With BoxyCharm, you’re spending $25 every month and getting full-size products every time. Over three months, that’s $75. But you’re getting 15-21 full-size items instead of one. Which one feels like a better deal?
What About the Freebies and Perks?
IPSY gives you access to the IPSY app where you can buy more products at discounts. They also have a rewards program. But you have to shop extra to get real value. BoxyCharm doesn’t have a rewards system. You get your box, and that’s it. No extra logins, no points to redeem. Just five to seven full-size items delivered monthly.
IPSY also lets you skip a month. BoxyCharm doesn’t. If you’re on vacation or just don’t want makeup for a while, IPSY lets you pause. BoxyCharm charges you anyway. That’s a small but real cost if your routine changes.
The Verdict: BoxyCharm Costs More Upfront, But Gives You More
Is BoxyCharm more expensive? Yes, on paper. $25 vs $12. But if you’re paying for actual usable beauty products-not samples-then BoxyCharm is the better value. You’re getting more product, more brand variety, and more long-term savings. IPSY is cheaper, but only if you’re okay with never fully using what you get.
If you’re someone who likes to experiment and doesn’t mind buying full-size products separately, stick with IPSY. But if you want to stop paying full retail price for makeup and get real, full-size products delivered every month, BoxyCharm is the smarter choice. You pay more each month, but you get more value. And in beauty, that’s what really matters.
Is IPSY really cheaper than BoxyCharm?
On a monthly fee basis, yes-IPSY’s base plan is $12 compared to BoxyCharm’s $25. But IPSY gives you mostly samples, while BoxyCharm gives you full-size products. If you factor in retail value, BoxyCharm often delivers $100-$150 worth of products for $25, making it a better value per item. IPSY’s $12 plan might feel cheaper, but you’re paying for small sizes that won’t last.
Can I get full-size products from IPSY?
Yes, but only if you upgrade to the Glam Bag Plus plan, which costs $25 a month. Even then, you usually get four samples and one full-size product. BoxyCharm, on the other hand, gives you five to seven full-size items every month with no upgrades needed. If you want full-size products consistently, BoxyCharm is the more reliable option.
Do both services ship internationally?
Yes, both ship internationally, but shipping adds $10-$15 per box for locations like Australia. That means IPSY’s $12 plan becomes $22-$27, and BoxyCharm’s $25 plan becomes $35-$40. The price gap narrows, so international users should compare the total cost-including shipping-before choosing.
Which service has better product quality?
Both include brands like Rare Beauty, Fenty, and Drunk Elephant. IPSY leans toward trending indie brands and samples of new launches. BoxyCharm focuses on established, full-size products from high-end brands. Quality is similar, but BoxyCharm gives you products you can actually use daily, while IPSY’s samples are better for testing.
Can I skip a month with BoxyCharm?
No, BoxyCharm doesn’t let you skip months. You’re charged every month regardless of whether you want the box. IPSY lets you pause your subscription anytime. If your beauty routine changes or you’re traveling, IPSY gives you more flexibility.
What to Do Next
If you’re still unsure, try both. IPSY’s $12 plan is a low-risk way to test what kinds of products you like. If you find yourself loving the samples and wanting more, switch to BoxyCharm. If you’re already buying full-size makeup regularly, BoxyCharm will save you money over time. Either way, don’t just look at the monthly price-look at what you’re actually getting. Beauty is personal. The best box is the one that fits your routine, not just your budget.
Hair Care
